The credit union had been serving the same rural Georgia community for 62 years.
It had been through recessions and the savings and loan crisis and the digital transition and every other financial weather system that the last six decades had produced.
And it had come through each of them with the particular institutional stubbornness of a community financial organization whose depositors are also its owners and whose failure would therefore be everyone’s failure simultaneously.
The woman who managed the member services desk on the morning of March 9th 2010 had been with the institution for 23 years.
She had processed in those 23 years thousands of transactions.
She had never processed one like this.
The account had last been touched in 1981.
The couple who had opened it were listed in the system as missing, a notation that had been added in 1983 at the request of the county sheriff’s department and that had been sitting in the record for 27 years without ever being triggered.
The man presenting identification for both account holders was not flustered.
He had the documentation.
He had practiced the particular stillness of someone who has been waiting a long time to do a thing and has had sufficient time to prepare himself for the doing of it.
He slid the documents across the desk and waited.
The member services manager looked at the documents.
She looked at her screen.
She looked at the notation.
She excused herself for a moment, stepped into the back office, and called the Telair County Sheriff’s Department.
That phone call made on a Tuesday morning in rural Georgia while a man sat at the member services desk with the stillness of long preparation would reach a detective named Marcus Webb and send him to an archive room where a 30-year-old case file would tell him everything he needed to know to find what had been hidden since the summer of 1981 on a property in the pine flatwoods of South Georgia.
But before any of that, we have to go back to that summer.
Because to understand what was lost, you first have to understand who James and Ellen Courtland were.
McCrae, Georgia, in the summer of 1981, had the quality of small South Georgia towns in that era.
A county seat of 4500 people at the center of a rural county where the economy ran on tobacco and timber and the specific knowledge of how to grow things in the particular soil and climate of the Georgia coastal plane.
The downtown had a hardware store and a feed store and a diner and a courthouse that had been there since 1890.
And that gave the square the specific authority of a building that has been the center of something for long enough that it no longer needs to announce itself.
The neighborhoods around the courthouse square were residential and walkable and connected to each other by the kind of social fabric that small county seats produce when the same families have been doing the same things in the same buildings for three and four generations.
James Whitfield Courtland was 30 years old.
He had grown up in McCrae, the son of a man named Earl, who had managed the county’s agricultural extension office for 21 years, and who had developed through those 21 years a comprehensive and practical knowledge of how the land and the families and the economy of Telair County fit together that he had passed in the particular way of fathers who do not formally teach, but continuously demonstrate to his son.
James had attended the University of Georgia on a partial scholarship and returned to McCrae after graduation with a degree in agricultural economics and a position at a regional bank that he had held for 4 years.
The kind of position that required him to evaluate farm loan applications with an understanding of the agricultural realities that the numbers on the page did not always capture and that he provided because Earl Courtland’s son understood the realities from the inside.
He had met Ellen at a church social in Savannah in the fall of 1978 during a weekend visit to a college friend and had spent the following six months pursuing a courtship conducted primarily by letter and by the phone calls that his telephone bill later reviewed by investigators documented as occurring three and four times a week with a regularity that his college friend described with affectionate accuracy as the behavior of a man who had made up his mind and was not interested in alternative outcomes.
Ellen Grace Courtland, born Ellen Grace Tanner, was 27 years old.
She had grown up in Savannah, the daughter of a man named Howard, who was a maritime insurance broker and a woman named Francis, who had sung in the choir of the Independent Presbyterian Church of Savannah for 31 years.
Ellen had studied art history at Armstrong State College and had been working for three years as the registars’s assistant at the Telfair Academy of Arts and Sciences in Savannah.
A position that required the management and documentation of one of the oldest art collections in the south with the specific combination of organizational rigor and cultural knowledge that the job demanded and that Ellen provided with the cheerful efficiency of someone who loves the material they are managing enough to take the management seriously.
She had moved to McCrae in January of 1981, 6 months before the wedding, to establish herself in the community that James lived in and that she would be joining.
A decision she had described in a letter to her college roommate, which the roommate provided to investigators years later as feeling like the right direction without feeling like a loss, which she said was the distinction that mattered.
They were married on July 11th, 1981 at the First United Methodist Church of McCrae in a ceremony that the town remembered in the way that communities of 4500 remember the weddings of people they have watched grow up with the specific proprietary warmth of a place that considers the happiness of its members to be in some collective sense its own.
The reception was held in the church fellowship hall organized by three generations of the Courtland family’s network of church and community connections and ran until 9 in the evening when James and Ellen left in a car decorated with the traditional attachments, streamers, tin cans, the chalk lettering on the rear window to begin the drive to Savannah where they were spending the first night before flying to Charleston for the honeymoon.
They never arrived in Savannah.
Ellen’s parents, Howard and Francis, waited until midnight and then called James’s parents.
Earl Courtland called the Telair County Sheriff’s Department at 12:30.
A deputy was dispatched.
By morning, a search had begun for the decorated car.
The car, a 1979 Buick Lasabre, silver with the chalk lettering and streamers still attached, was found two days later on a county road 12 m from McCrae in a direction that was not toward Savannah and that had no logical destination that corresponded to where James and Ellen were going.
The road ran through pine flatwoods toward a network of logging roads used by the timber operations in the area.
The car was parked on the shoulder.
The streamers were still on the doors.
One of the tin cans had come loose from the rear bumper and was lying in the road 10 ft behind the car.
The chalk lettering on the rear window was still partially legible.
The part that said just married had survived the evening air.
The driver’s door was unlocked.
Ellen’s wedding purse was on the passenger seat.
James’s jacket, the one he had worn to the ceremony, was folded on the back seat.
A biological sample was collected from the car’s interior.
A partial bootprint was found in the soft shoulder beside the driver’s door.
The bootprint suggested a men’s size 12, a wide width.
In July of 1981, DINA analysis for law enforcement did not exist in Georgia or anywhere else.
The sample was preserved.
The bootprint was cast in plaster.
Both went into the Telair County Evidence Archive.
The lead investigator, a detective named Roy Gaines, had been with the department for 16 years.
And approached the Courtland case with the methodical thoroughess of someone who understands that the absence of immediate leads is not the absence of a case, but the presence of one that requires more patience than most.
He ran the established tracks.
He identified the guests who had attended the reception and confirmed their departures, established the approximate time that James and Ellen had left, and constructed a timeline that placed the decorated car on the county road sometime between 9:30 and 11:00 on the night of July 11th.
The property adjacent to the county road where the car was found was owned by a man named Curtis Dean Wear.
He was 41 years old in 1981.
He had lived on the property for 8 years, having purchased it in 1973 from a timber company that had finished its operations in that section of the county.
He ran a small equipment repair operation from the property, tractors, chainsaws, timber equipment, and had a documented working relationship with several of the county’s farming and timber operations, which meant he was a known figure in the community without being a prominent one.
He was unmarried.
He had no prior criminal record.
He was interviewed by Roy Gaines on the third day of the investigation as part of a canvas of property owners adjacent to the road where the car had been found.
He was cooperative.
He said he had not heard anything unusual on the night of July 11th.
He said the road was sometimes used by people who wanted to park.
That it happened that he had not paid attention to it that night.
He said he did not know James and Ellen Courtland beyond recognizing the Courtland name as a family from McCrae.
His boots, which Gaines noted in his interview record, were a size 12 wide width.
Gaines recorded the observation without acting on it because a boot size was not evidence and an interview observation was not probable cause and Roy Gaines was a thorough investigator who understood the difference between suspicion and proof.
He noted it.
He moved on.
He kept moving for four years until the case went inactive in 1985 and he was reassigned to a department that had more active cases than a small county’s investigative division could adequately staff.
He added a notation to the inside cover of the case file before he closed it.
Property adjacent to discovery site.
C D where interview noted boots size 12W biological evidence viable do not destroy.
Curtis Dean Wear continued to operate his equipment repair business on the Pine Flatwoods property for the next 29 years.
Earl Courtland had retired from the agricultural extension office in 1988.
He had spent the seven years between the wedding and his retirement making calls, driving roads, maintaining the specific pressure on the Telair County Sheriff’s Department that a man who knows the county’s institutional architecture can apply when he understands which calls reach which people and how to make each one count.
After retirement, with more time available, he had intensified rather than reduced this effort.
He had driven the county road where the Buick had been found every month for 29 years.
He had not always stopped.
He had sometimes only driven past slowly as a form of marking.
Francis Tanner, Ellen’s mother, had not recovered from the loss in the way that the word recover implies a destination.
She had continued, which is the more accurate description.
She had continued to sing in the choir at Independent Presbyterian, had continued to be present in the life of the Savannah community, had continued to be Howard’s wife and the person her friends relied on for the specific qualities she had always provided.
She had continued doing all of it with the part of herself that remained functional, while the other part, the part that was Ellen’s mother, had been living since July of 1981 in the suspension of an unresolved question that continuing did not resolve.
Howard Tanner had hired a private investigator in 1986, 5 years after the disappearance, using money he had set aside from the maritime insurance practice.
The investigator had worked the case for eight months and produced a report that was thorough and well organized and added nothing of substance to what Roy Gaines had already documented.
Howard paid the invoice and filed the report in the folder he kept in his study alongside the copies of Roy Gaines’s case file that the Telair County Sheriff’s Department had provided through a public records request in 1984.
He read the private investigator’s report three times and put it in the folder and did not hire another investigator.
Not because he had given up, but because he understood that the answer was not in the quality of the investigation.
The investigation had been thorough, but in the quality of the evidence, which was preserved and waiting for a science that did not yet exist.
He had read enough about the development of DINA forensics in the late 1980s and early 1990s to understand what it was going to mean for unsolved cases.
He had called the Telair County Sheriff’s Department in 1994 and asked specifically whether the biological evidence from the Courtland case had been preserved and whether the department intended to submit it for Dina analysis when the protocols became available in Georgia.
He had been told yes to the first question and yes to the second.
He had called again in 1998 and in 2003 and in 2007.
Each time he had been told the evidence was preserved and the case was under periodic review.
Each time he had thanked the person he was speaking to and made a note in the folder with the date of the call and the name of the person and what they had said.
The folder was 2 in thick by 2010.
Howard was 73 years old and the folder was 2 in thick and he had every intention of living long enough to see what it had been accumulating toward.
Every case on this channel is built from weeks of research through archived county files, court records, and the family histories of people who built folders and drove roads and made calls for decades.
Because the alternative was silence and silence was not acceptable.
If this work matters to you, take a moment to like this video, subscribe, and drop a comment below telling us where in the world you’re watching from.
Your support makes this possible.
Now, back to March of 2010, and the man with the stillness of long preparation sitting at the member services desk.
Marcus Webb had been with the Telair County Sheriff’s Department for 6 years when the credit union’s call reached the detective division on the morning of March 9th, 2010.
He was 34 years old and had inherited the Courtland case file in 2007 from his predecessor who had inherited it from his predecessor with the institutional continuity of a file that nobody had been willing to formally close because Roy Gaines’s notation on the inside cover, do not destroy, had acquired through repetition and time the force of a department directive.
Webb had read the file in 2007.
He had read it again in 2008 when he submitted the biological evidence for DINA profiling through the Georgia Bureau of Investigations updated cold case protocol.
A submission that produced a profile but no match in the state or national database.
He had read it a third time on the morning of March 9th, 2010.
Driving to the credit union with the member services manager’s account of the transaction and the man who had not been flustered still ringing in his mind.
The man’s name established through fingerprints taken when Webb arrived at the credit union and the man declined to provide identification voluntarily was Curtis Dean Wear.
He was 70 years old.
He had sold his Pine Flatwoods property in Telair County in 2004.
And moved to a community in Dodge County, one county north, where he had been living for six years in a house that his neighbors described as well-maintained and whose owner they described as quiet and solitary and no trouble to anyone.
He was 29 years from his first interview with Roy Gaines.
He was 29 years from the July night when Roy Gaines had noted his boots and moved on.
He had, by the evidence that Marcus Webb was beginning to assemble in the hours following the credit union identification, maintained James and Ellen Courtland’s identification documents for 29 years, not destroyed them, not discarded them, kept them in the way that Curtisine Wear kept things, which was carefully and in good order.
As a man who repairs equipment for a living, keeps things that might eventually be useful.
Webb obtained a warrant for the Dodge County property.
The search was conducted over two days, March 10th and 11th, 2010, with a Georgia Bureau of Investigation forensic team and a cadaavver detection unit brought in from the regional office in Valdasta.
The cadaavver dogs indicated on the first afternoon in an area of the property’s rear boundary that backed against a stand of long leaf pines.
Ground penetrating radar confirmed subsurface anomalies consistent with the cadaavver indication.
Excavation began on March 11th.
James and Ellen Courtland were found.
They were identified through dental records.
James is from a Telair County dentist whose practice had been absorbed by a larger office in the 1990s, but whose historical records had been retained in the acquiring practices archive.
And Ellens from a Savannah dentist whose records required a search through the Chattam County Dental Society’s historical membership records that took 11 days.
The identifications were confirmed on March 22nd, 2010, 28 years and 8 months after they had driven away from the First United Methodist Church of McCrae with chalk lettering on the rear window.
The biological evidence from the 1981 Buick Lasabber was resubmitted for comparison against a Dena sample obtained from Curtis Dean wear through the booking process.
The match was confirmed.
The boots in Roy Gaines’s interview notation were a size 12 wide width.
The boots were consistent.
The Dena was not consistent.
The Dena was definitive.
Curtis Dean Wear was charged with two counts of aggravated murder and two counts of identity fraud.
He said nothing at arrest.
He said nothing at booking.
He said nothing at arraignment where his attorney entered not guilty please on all counts.
He had the stillness in the courtroom as he had had it at the member services desk of someone who has made a decision about what to give to the moment and has decided that the answer is nothing.
The prosecution built its case on the Dena match.
The identity documents found at the Dodge County property.
The geographic evidence placing We’s property adjacent to the county road where the Courtland car had been found in July 1981.
And Roy Gaines’s 1981 interview notation about the boot size presented not as evidence of guilt but as evidence of the investigative foundation that had preserved the case for 29 years.
The notation was read into the trial record.
Roy Gaines, reached by Marcus Webb in retirement in Florida, was asked whether he would be willing to provide a deposition.
He said he had been waiting for the call since 1985.
He gave the deposition by video from his living room in Clearwater.
He was 78 years old.
He testified with the precision of someone who has been reviewing the same set of facts in his memory for 25 years and has had sufficient time to get them exactly right.
Curtis Dean Wear was convicted on all counts in 2012.
The jury deliberated for 8 hours.
He was sentenced to consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole, plus an additional federal term for the identity fraud.
The judge noted at sentencing that the identity documents maintained for 29 years constituted evidence of the defendant’s ongoing awareness of his guilt.
That a man who keeps the identification of his victims for three decades is a man who has never stopped knowing what he did and has simply decided that knowing and concealing are compatible with a continued life.
They are not compatible.
The judge said the law when it arrives makes them incompatible.
Earl Courtland was 81 years old when Marcus Webb called him on March 10th, 2010.
Webb told him they had found James and Ellen.
He told him where.
He told him that Curtisine Wear was in custody.
Earl was quiet for a long time.
Then he said he had driven that county road every month for 29 years and that the property adjacent to the road had belonged to Curtis Wear and that he had known this for 29 years and had felt in the monthly drives something he could not name that he now understood was his instincts telling him what his evidence could not confirm.
He said he wished he had been able to do something with that.
Webb told him that Roy Gaines had felt the same way.
Earl said he knew.
He had spoken to Gaines twice in the years after the investigation, and Gaines had told him about the boots and the notation and the preservation of the evidence.
He said Roy Gaines was a thorough man.
He said thorough men were worth the world.
He said he was going to need to call Francis.
Howard Tanner was 73 years old and the folder was 2 in thick.
He had called the department in 2007 and been told the evidence was preserved and the case was under review.
He had made a note in the folder.
He had not imagined that the review would be triggered by a credit union transaction and a member services manager who recognized a notation that had been sitting in the record for 27 years.
He had imagined it would come from the biology, from the Dina match, the science arriving in the form he had read about and understood and waited for.
It had come from both, the notation and the biology together, as Roy Gaines had intended when he wrote one and preserved the other.
Howard read his 2-in folder at the kitchen table the evening of March 9th after Web’s call.
He read it from the beginning, which was a letter he had written to the Telair County Sheriff’s Department in August of 1981 through the private investigator’s report and the records request copies and the notes from 29 years of calls with dates and names and what had been said.
He read it to the end, which was a blank page that he had always kept at the back, folded in half for the information that would eventually close it.
He unfolded the blank page.
He wrote the date and the name and what Marcus Webb had told him.
Then he closed the folder.
Francis had died in 2008, 2 years before the arrest.
She had sung in the choir at Independent Presbyterian until 2006 when her health had made the Sunday commitments unreliable.
She had sung for 31 years before Ellen and 25 years after, and the choir had held a place for her in the alto section for the two years she could not attend because the director understood that her absence was temporary and that her return, if it came, would require the place to have been kept.
She had returned in the summer of 2007 for three months before her health prevented it again.
She had sung in July of 2007, which was the 26th anniversary of the wedding.
And the director had chosen, without announcing it, a hymn that Francis had requested in 1982 for the memorial service the church had held that year for James and Ellen.
Francis had noticed.
She had sung it the way she had always sung, present, full.
The note held for its complete duration.
Nothing withheld.
Howard read the folder to the end and wrote the date and the name and closed it.
Then he called the choir director at Independent Presbyterian and told him the news.
The director said he would tell the choir.
Howard said he thought Francis would have been glad to know.
The director said he was certain she would have been.
Howard said he thought on reflection that she probably did know that the specific quality of her return in 2007.
The way she had sung the July hymn suggested that she had been carrying the knowledge of the right direction even if she had not lived to receive the confirmation.
He said this was the kind of thing that was impossible to prove and that he believed it completely.
The director said he understood.
He said he had been leading choirs for 40 years and that the relationship between faith and certainty was in his experience a subject on which precision was neither available nor required.
James Whitfield Courtland had returned to the county where he had grown up because the community’s knowledge of how its land and families and economy fit together was something he could contribute to.
And that contributing to mattered.
Ellen Grace Tanner had moved to McCrae six months before the wedding because the right direction was not a loss and because she understood that the distinction mattered.
They drove away from the First United Methodist Church on a July evening with chalk lettering on the rear window and tin cans on the bumper and the direction of Savannah ahead of them and everything.
In that moment, still the direction of something rather than the direction of something else.
Curtis Dean Wear lived on the property adjacent to the county road for 23 more years after July of 1981.
He maintained equipment on that property.
He kept the identification documents.
He sold the property in 2004 and moved one county north and maintained the documents there.
He presented them at a member services desk in March of 2010 with the stillness of long preparation and triggered a notation that had been sitting in a credit union’s record for 27 years waiting for exactly this.
Roy Gaines had written do not destroy in 1985 because he understood that the evidence was the case and that the case would close when the evidence found its science.
Marcus Webb had read that notation and submitted the evidence and received a match and driven to a credit union and found a man with a folder of documents sitting with the practiced stillness of someone who had had 29 years to prepare for the moment he apparently believed he had earned.
He had not earned it.
He had built 29 years on the foundation of what he had done.
And the foundation was what the Dena and the notation and the member services manager’s phone call and Roy Gaines’s deposition from a living room in Clearwater assembled into a verdict and a sentence.
The verdict was unanimous.
The sentence was the remainder of his life.
Howard Tanner closed the folder.
Earl Courtland drove the county road one last time.
Francis had sung in July of 2007 in a way that Howard could not prove and believed completely.
James and Ellen were buried in McCrae in the Courtland family plot at the cemetery east of town in the fall of 2010, 29 years after the chalk lettering on the rear window had said just married and the tin cans had rattled south toward a night that had gone in a direction that none of the people who watched them drive away had been able to imagine.
The chalk had long since faded from the rear window.
Everything else had been preserved.
What does it tell you about the relationship between institutional memory and justice that a credit union notation entered at the request of a county sheriff in 1983 was still active in the record 27 years later and was the mechanism that triggered the break in the case and that the institution’s 62 years of community service included without knowing it the 27-year preservation of a flag that would eventually matter.
Does the discovery that Curtis Dean Wear kept the identification documents for 29 years change how you understand what he was?
Not a man who committed a crime and moved on, but a man who kept the evidence of the crime as a possession.
And what does that suggest about the nature of what he had done?
And what do you make of Howard Tanner’s 2-in folder closed on the evening of March 9th, 2010 with a blank page at the back finally written on and the choir director’s understanding that between faith and certainty.
Precision is neither available nor our couple vanished after wedding in 1981.
29 years later, their IDs were used to drain their money.
The credit union had been serving the same rural Georgia community for 62 years.
It had been through recessions and the savings and loan crisis and the digital transition and every other financial weather system that the last six decades had produced.
And it had come through each of them with the particular institutional stubbornness of a community financial organization whose depositors are also its owners and whose failure would therefore be everyone’s failure simultaneously.
The woman who managed the member services desk on the morning of March 9th, 2010 had been with the institution for 23 years.
She had processed in those 23 years thousands of transactions.
She had never processed one like this.
The account had last been touched in 1981.
The couple who had opened it were listed in the system as missing, a notation that had been added in 1983 at the request of the county sheriff’s department and that had been sitting in the record for 27 years without ever being triggered.
The man presenting identification for both account holders was not flustered.
He had the documentation.
He had practiced the particular stillness of someone who has been waiting a long time to do a thing and has had sufficient time to prepare himself for the doing of it.
He slid the documents across the desk and waited.
The member services manager looked at the documents.
She looked at her screen.
She looked at the notation.
She excused herself for a moment, stepped into the back office, and called the Telair County Sheriff’s Department.
That phone call made on a Tuesday morning in rural Georgia while a man sat at the member services desk with the stillness of long preparation would reach a detective named Marcus Webb and send him to an archive room where a 30-year-old case file would tell him everything he needed to know to find what had been hidden since the summer of 1981 on a property in the pine flatwoods of South Georgia.
But before any of that, we have to go back to that summer.
Because to understand what was lost, you first have to understand who James and Ellen Courtland were.
McCrae, Georgia in the summer of 1981 had the quality of small South Georgia towns in that era.
A county seat of 4500 people at the center of a rural county where the economy ran on tobacco and timber and the specific knowledge of how to grow things in the particular soil and climate of the Georgia coastal plane.
The downtown had a hardware store and a feed store and a diner and a courthouse that had been there since 1890 and that gave the square the specific authority of a building that has been the center of something for long enough that it no longer needs to announce itself.
The neighborhoods around the courthouse square were residential and walkable and connected to each other by the kind of social fabric that small county seats produce when the same families have been doing the same things in the same buildings for three and four generations.
James Whitfield Courtland was 30 years old.
He had grown up in McCrae, the son of a man named Earl, who had managed the county’s agricultural extension office for 21 years, and who had developed through those 21 years a comprehensive and practical knowledge of how the land and the families and the economy of Telair County fit together that he had passed in the particular way of fathers who do not formally teach but continuously demonstrate to his son.
James had attended the University of Georgia on a partial scholarship and returned to McCrae after graduation with a degree in agricultural economics and a position at a regional bank that he had held for four years.
The kind of position that required him to evaluate farm loan applications with an understanding of the agricultural realities that the numbers on the page did not always capture and that he provided because Earl Courtland’s son understood the realities from the inside.
He had met Ellen at a church social in Savannah in the fall of 1978 during a weekend visit to a college friend and had spent the following six months pursuing a courtship conducted primarily by letter and by the phone calls that his telephone bill later reviewed by investigators documented as occurring three and four times a week with a regularity that his college friend described with affectionate accuracy as the behavior of a man who had made up his mind and was not interested in alternative outcomes.
Ellen Grace Courtland, born Ellen Grace Tanner, was 27 years old.
She had grown up in Savannah, the daughter of a man named Howard, who was a maritime insurance broker and a woman named Francis, who had sung in the choir of the Independent Presbyterian Church of Savannah for 31 years.
Ellen had studied art history at Armstrong State College and had been working for three years as the registars’s assistant at the Telair Academy of Arts and Sciences in Savannah.
A position that required the management and documentation of one of the oldest art collections in the south with the specific combination of organizational rigor and cultural knowledge that the job demanded and that Ellen provided with the cheerful efficiency of someone who loves the material they are managing enough to take the management seriously.
She had moved to McCrae in January of 1981, 6 months before the wedding, to establish herself in the community that James lived in and that she would be joining.
A decision she had described in a letter to her college roommate, which the roommate provided to investigators years later, as feeling like the right direction without feeling like a loss, which she said was the distinction that mattered.
They were married on July 11th, 1981 at the First United Methodist Church of McCrae in a ceremony that the town remembered in the way that communities of 4500 remember the weddings of people they have watched grow up, with the specific proprietary warmth of a place that considers the happiness of its members to be in some collective sense its own.
The reception was held in the church fellowship hall, organized by three generations of the Courtland family’s network of church and community connections and ran until 9 in the evening when James and Ellen left in a car decorated with the traditional attachments, streamers, tin cans, the chalk lettering on the rear window to begin the drive to Savannah, where they were spending the first night before flying to Charleston for the honeymoon.
They never arrived in Savannah.
Ellen’s parents, Howard and Francis, waited until midnight and then called James’s parents.
Earl Courtland called the Telair County Sheriff’s Department at 12:30.
A deputy was dispatched.
By morning, a search had begun for the decorated car.
The car, a 1979 Buick Lasabre, silver with the chalk lettering and streamers still attached, was found two days later on a county road 12 m from McCrae in a direction that was not toward Savannah and that had no logical destination that corresponded to where James and Ellen were going.
The road ran through Pine Flatwoods toward a network of logging roads used by the timber operations in the area.
The car was parked on the shoulder.
The streamers were still on the doors.
One of the tin cans had come loose from the rear bumper and was lying in the road 10 ft behind the car.
The chalk lettering on the rear window was still partially legible.
The part that said just married had survived the evening air.
The driver’s door was unlocked.
Ellen’s wedding purse was on the passenger seat.
James’s jacket, the one he had worn to the ceremony, was folded on the back seat.
A biological sample was collected from the car’s interior.
A partial bootprint was found in the soft shoulder beside the driver’s door.
The bootprint suggested a men’s size 12, a wide width.
In July of 1981, Dena analysis for law enforcement did not exist in Georgia or anywhere else.
The sample was preserved.
The bootprint was cast in plaster.
Both went into the Telair County evidence archive.
The lead investigator, a detective named Roy Gaines, had been with the department for 16 years and approached the Courtland case with the methodical thoroughess of someone who understands that the absence of immediate leads is not the absence of a case, but the presence of one that requires more patience than most.
He ran the established tracks.
He identified the guests who had attended the reception and confirmed their departures.
Established the approximate time that James and Ellen had left and constructed a timeline that placed the decorated car on the county road sometime between 9:30 and 11:00 on the night of July 11th.
The property adjacent to the county road where the car was found was owned by a man named Curtis Dean Wear.
He was 41 years old in 1981.
He had lived on the property for 8 years, having purchased it in 1973 from a timber company that had finished its operations in that section of the county.
He ran a small equipment repair operation from the property, tractors, chainsaws, timber equipment, and had a documented working relationship with several of the county’s farming and timber operations, which meant he was a known figure in the community without being a prominent one.
He was unmarried.
He had no prior criminal record.
He was interviewed by Roy Gaines on the third day of the investigation as part of a canvas of property owners adjacent to the road where the car had been found.
He was cooperative.
He said he had not heard anything unusual on the night of July 11th.
He said the road was sometimes used by people who wanted to park.
That it happened that he had not paid attention to it that night.
He said he did not know James and Ellen Courtland beyond recognizing the Courtland name as a family from Mcgra.
His boots, which Gaines noted in his interview record, were a size 12 wide width.
Gaines recorded the observation without acting on it because a boot size was not evidence and an interview observation was not probable cause and Roy Gaines was a thorough investigator who understood the difference between suspicion and proof.
He noted it.
He moved on.
He kept moving for four years until the case went inactive in 1985 and he was reassigned to a department that had more active cases than a small county’s investigative division could adequately staff.
He added a notation to the inside cover of the case file before he closed it.
Property adjacent to discovery site.
CD wear.
Interview noted.
Boots size 12W.
Biological evidence viable.
Do not destroy.
Curtis Dean Wear continued to operate his equipment repair business on the Pine Flatwoods property for the next 29 years.
Earl Courtland had retired from the agricultural extension office in 1988.
He had spent the seven years between the wedding and his retirement making calls, driving roads, maintaining the specific pressure on the Telair County Sheriff’s Department that a man who knows the county’s institutional architecture can apply when he understands which calls reach which people and how to make each one count.
After retirement, with more time available, he had intensified rather than reduced this effort.
He had driven the county road where the Buick had been found every month for 29 years.
He had not always stopped.
He had sometimes only driven past slowly as a form of marking.
Francis Tanner, Ellen’s mother, had not recovered from the loss in the way that the word recover implies a destination.
She had continued, which is the more accurate description.
She had continued to sing in the choir at Independent Presbyterian, had continued to be present in the life of the Savannah community, had continued to be Howard’s wife and the person her friends relied on for the specific qualities she had always provided.
She had continued doing all of it with the part of herself that remained functional, while the other part, the part that was Ellen’s mother, had been living since July of 1981, in the suspension of an unresolved question that continuing did not resolve.
Howard Tanner had hired a private investigator in 1986, 5 years after the disappearance, using money he had set aside from the maritime insurance practice.
The investigator had worked the case for eight months and produced a report that was thorough and well organized and added nothing of substance to what Roy Gaines had already documented.
Howard paid the invoice and filed the report in the folder he kept in his study alongside the copies of Roy Gaines’s case file that the Telair County Sheriff’s Department had provided through a public records request in 1984.
He read the private investigator’s report three times and put it in the folder and did not hire another investigator.
Not because he had given up, but because he understood that the answer was not in the quality of the investigation.
The investigation had been thorough, but in the quality of the evidence, which was preserved and waiting for a science that did not yet exist.
He had read enough about the development of DINA forensics in the late 1980s and early 1990s to understand what it was going to mean for unsolved cases.
He had called the Telair County Sheriff’s Department in 1994 and asked specifically whether the biological evidence from the Courtland case had been preserved and whether the department intended to submit it for Dina analysis when the protocols became available in Georgia.
He had been told yes to the first question and yes to the second.
He had called again in 1998 and in 2003 and in 2007.
Each time he had been told the evidence was preserved and the case was under periodic review.
Each time he had thanked the person he was speaking to and made a note in the folder with the date of the call and the name of the person and what they had said.
The folder was 2 in thick by 2010.
Howard was 73 years old and the folder was 2 in thick and he had every intention of living long enough to see what it had been accumulating toward.
Every case on this channel is built from weeks of research through archived county files, court records, and the family histories of people who built folders and drove roads and made calls for decades.
Because the alternative was silence and silence was not acceptable.
If this work matters to you, take a moment to like this video, subscribe, and drop a comment below telling us where in the world you’re watching from.
Your support makes this possible.
Now, back to March of 2010 and the man with the stillness of long preparation sitting at the member services desk.
Marcus Webb had been with the Telair County Sheriff’s Department for six years when the credit union’s call reached the detective division on the morning of March 9th, 2010.
He was 34 years old and had inherited the Courtland case file in 2007 from his predecessor who had inherited it from his predecessor with the institutional continuity of a file that nobody had been willing to formally close because Roy Gaines’s notation on the inside cover do not destroy had acquired through repetition and time the force of a department directive.
Webb had read the file in 2007.
He had read it again in 2008 when he submitted the biological evidence for DINA profiling through the Georgia Bureau of Investigations updated cold case protocol.
A submission that produced a profile but no match in the state or national database.
He had read it a third time on the morning of March 9th, 2010.
Driving to the credit union with the member services manager’s account of the transaction and the man who had not been flustered still ringing in his mind.
The man’s name established through fingerprints taken when Webb arrived at the credit union and the man declined to provide identification voluntarily was Curtis Dean wear.
He was 70 years old.
He had sold his Pine Flatwoods property in Telair County in 2004.
And moved to a community in Dodge County, one county north, where he had been living for six years in a house that his neighbors described as well-maintained and whose owner they described as quiet and solitary and no trouble to anyone.
He was 29 years from his first interview with Roy Gaines.
He was 29 years from the July night when Roy Gaines had noted his boots and moved on.
He had, by the evidence that Marcus Webb was beginning to assemble in the hours following the credit union identification, maintained James and Ellen Courtland’s identification documents for 29 years, not destroyed them, not discarded them, kept them in the way that Curtisine Wear kept things, which was carefully and in good order, as a man who repairs equipment for a living keeps things that might eventually be useful.
Webb obtained a warrant for the Dodge County property.
The search was conducted over two days, March 10th and 11th, 2010, with a Georgia Bureau of Investigation forensic team and a cadaavver detection unit brought in from the regional office in Valdasta.
The cadaavver dogs indicated on the first afternoon in an area of the property’s rear boundary that backed against a stand of long leaf pines.
Ground penetrating radar confirmed subsurface anomalies consistent with the cadaavver indication.
Excavation began on March 11th.
James and Ellen Courtland were found.
They were identified through dental records.
James is from a Telair County dentist whose practice had been absorbed by a larger office in the 1990s, but whose historical records had been retained in the acquiring practices archive and Ellens from a Savannah dentist whose records required a search through the Chattam County Dental Society’s historical membership records that took 11 days.
The identifications were confirmed on March 22nd, 2010.
28 years and eight months after they had driven away from the First United Methodist Church of McCrae with chalk lettering on the rear window.
The biological evidence from the 1981 Buick Lasabri was resubmitted for comparison against a Dena sample obtained from Curtis Dean wear through the booking process.
The match was confirmed.
The boots in Roy Gaines’s interview notation were a size 12 wide width.
The boots were consistent.
The Dena was not consistent.
The Dena was definitive.
Curtis Dean Wear was charged with two counts of aggravated murder and two counts of identity fraud.
He said nothing at arrest.
He said nothing at booking.
He said nothing at arraignment where his attorney entered not guilty p on all counts.
He had the stillness in the courtroom as he had had it at the member services desk of someone who has made a decision about what to give to the moment and has decided that the answer is nothing.
The prosecution built its case on the Dena match.
The identity documents found at the Dodge County property.
The geographic evidence placing Wear’s property adjacent to the county road where the Courtland car had been found in July 1981 and Roy Gaines’s 1981 interview notation about the boot size presented not as evidence of guilt but as evidence of the investigative foundation that had preserved the case for 29 years.
The notation was read into the trial record.
Roy Gaines, reached by Marcus Webb in retirement in Florida, was asked whether he would be willing to provide a deposition.
He said he had been waiting for the call since 1985.
He gave the deposition by video from his living room in Clearwater.
He was 78 years old.
He testified with the precision of someone who has been reviewing the same set of facts in his memory for 25 years and has had sufficient time to get them exactly right.
Curtis Dean Wear was convicted on all counts in 2012.
The jury deliberated for 8 hours.
He was sentenced to consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole plus an additional federal term for the identity fraud.
The judge noted at sentencing that the identity documents maintained for 29 years constituted evidence of the defendant’s ongoing awareness of his guilt.
That a man who keeps the identification of his victims for three decades is a man who has never stopped knowing what he did and has simply decided that knowing and concealing are compatible with a continued life.
They are not compatible.
The judge said the law when it arrives makes them incompatible.
Earl Courtland was 81 years old when Marcus Webb called him on March 10th, 2010.
Webb told him they had found James and Ellen.
He told him where.
He told him that Curtis Dean Wear was in custody.
Earl was quiet for a long time.
Then he said he had driven that county road every month for 29 years and that the property adjacent to the road had belonged to Curtis Wear and that he had known this for 29 years and had felt in the monthly drives something he could not name that he now understood was his instincts telling him what his evidence could not confirm.
He said he wished he had been able to do something with that.
Webb told him that Roy Gaines had felt the same way.
Earl said he knew.
He had spoken to Gaines twice in the years after the investigation, and Gaines had told him about the boots and the notation and the preservation of the evidence.
He said Roy Gaines was a thorough man.
He said thorough men were worth the world.
He said he was going to need to call Francis.
Howard Tanner was 73 years old and the folder was 2 in thick.
He had called the department in 2007 and been told the evidence was preserved and the case was under review.
He had made a note in the folder.
He had not imagined that the review would be triggered by a credit union transaction and a member services manager who recognized a notation that had been sitting in the record for 27 years.
He had imagined it would come from the biology, from the dena match, the science arriving in the form he had read about and understood and waited for.
It had come from both, the notation and the biology together, as Roy Gaines had intended when he wrote one and preserved the other.
Howard read his 2-in folder at the kitchen table the evening of March 9th after Web’s call.
He read it from the beginning, which was a letter he had written to the Telair County Sheriff’s Department in August of 1981 through the private investigator’s report and the records request copies and the notes from 29 years of calls with dates and names and what had been said.
He read it to the end, which was a blank page that he had always kept at the back, folded in half for the information that would eventually close it.
He unfolded the blank page.
He wrote the date and the name and what Marcus Webb had told him.
Then he closed the folder.
Francis had died in 2008, 2 years before the arrest.
She had sung in the choir at Independent Presbyterian until 2006 when her health had made the Sunday commitments unreliable.
She had sung for 31 years before Ellen and 25 years after, and the choir had held a place for her in the alto section for the two years she could not attend because the director understood that her absence was temporary and that her return, if it came, would require the place to have been kept.
She had returned in the summer of 2007 for 3 months before her health prevented it again.
She had sung in July of 2007, which was the 26th anniversary of the wedding, and the director had chosen, without announcing it, a hymn that Francis had requested in 1982 for the memorial service the church had held that year for James and Ellen.
Francis had noticed she had sung it the way she had always sung, present, full.
The note held for its complete duration.
Nothing withheld.
Howard read the folder to the end and wrote the date and the name and closed it.
Then he called the choir director at Independent Presbyterian and told him the news.
The director said he would tell the choir.
Howard said he thought Francis would have been glad to know.
The director said he was certain she would have been.
Howard said he thought on reflection that she probably did know that the specific quality of her return in 2007, the way she had sung the July hymn, suggested that she had been carrying the knowledge of the right direction, even if she had not lived to receive the confirmation.
He said this was the kind of thing that was impossible to prove and that he believed it completely.
The director said he understood.
He said he had been leading choirs for 40 years and that the relationship between faith and certainty was in his experience a subject on which precision was neither available nor required.
James Whitfield Courtland had returned to the county where he had grown up because the community’s knowledge of how its land and families and economy fit together was something he could contribute to and that contributing to mattered.
Ellen Grace Tanner had moved to McCrae six months before the wedding because the right direction was not a loss and because she understood that the distinction mattered.
They drove away from the First United Methodist Church on a July evening with chalk lettering on the rear window and tin cans on the bumper and the direction of Savannah ahead of them and everything.
In that moment, still the direction of something rather than the direction of something else.
Curtis Dean Wear lived on the property adjacent to the county road for 23 more years after July of 1981.
He maintained equipment on that property.
He kept the identification documents.
He sold the property in 2004 and moved one county north and maintained the documents there.
He presented them at a member services desk in March of 2010 with the stillness of long preparation and triggered a notation that had been sitting in a credit union’s record for 27 years waiting for exactly this.
Roy Gaines had written do not destroy in 1985 because he understood that the evidence was the case and that the case would close when the evidence found its science.
Marcus Webb had read that notation and submitted the evidence and received a match and driven to a credit union and found a man with a folder of documents sitting with the practiced stillness of someone who had had 29 years to prepare for the moment he apparently believed he had earned.
He had not earned it.
He had built 29 years on the foundation of what he had done.
And the foundation was what the dena and the notation and the member services manager’s phone call and Roy Gaines’s deposition from a living room in Clearwater assembled into a verdict and a sentence.
The verdict was unanimous.
The sentence was the remainder of his life.
Howard Tanner closed the folder.
Earl Courtland drove the county road one last time.
Francis had sung in July of 2007 in a way that Howard could not prove and believed completely.
James and Ellen were buried in McCrae in the Courtland family plot at the cemetery east of town in the fall of 2010, 29 years after the chalk lettering on the rear window had said just married and the tin cans had rattled south toward a night that had gone in a direction that none of the people who watched them drive away had been able to imagine.
The chalk had long since faded from the rear window.
Everything else had been preserved.
What does it tell you about the relationship between institutional memory and justice that a credit union notation entered at the request of a county sheriff in 1983 was still active in the record 27 years later and was the mechanism that triggered the break in the case and that the institution’s 62 years of community service included without knowing it the 27-year preservation of a flag that would eventually matter.
Does the discovery that Curtis Dean Wear kept the identification documents for 29 years change how you understand what he was?
Not a man who committed a crime and moved on, but a man who kept the evidence of the crime as a possession?
And what does that suggest about the nature of what he had done?
And what do you make of Howard Tanner’s 2-in folder closed on the evening of March 9th, 2010, with the blank page at the back finally written on, and the choir director’s understanding that between faith and certainty, precision is neither available nor required.
Justice found James and Ellen Courtland after 29 years.
Stories like theirs are why this channel exists.
If you believe the truth is worth pursuing, no matter how long it takes, subscribe so you don’t miss the next case.
More cases are waiting in the description below.
Thank you for being here.
Acquired justice found James and Ellen Courtland after 29 years.
Stories like theirs are why this channel exists.
If you believe the truth is worth pursuing no matter how long it takes, subscribe so you don’t miss the next case.
More cases are waiting in the description below.
Thank you for being here.
